- Recall issued: March 25, 2025
- Company: Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc.
- Product: Lillie’s Q Buffalo Wing Sauce
- Issue: Undeclared milk allergen (not listed as sub-ingredient of butter or in the “Contains” statement)
- Product details: 13.5 oz bottles, specific lot numbers and dates (see table below)
- What to do: Consumers with milk allergies should not consume this product; return or dispose
- Call to action: Wanna know more about what happened? Keep on reading.
What happened?
Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc. has recalled 8,532 bottles of Lillie’s Q Buffalo Wing Sauce due to an undeclared milk allergen that was in both the ingredient list and the “Contains” statement.
This Class II recall was initiated on March 25, 2025, following the company’s internal discovery of the labeling oversight. Though the risk is considered moderate and typically results in temporary or reversible health effects, it’s no small deal for those with milk allergies.
The affected bottles were distributed to centers across Kansas, Florida, New Hampshire, California, Iowa, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, Connecticut, Wisconsin, New York, Washington, and Pennsylvania.
Brand | Product | Size | UPC | Best By Date | Issue |
Lillie’s Q | Buffalo Wing Sauce | 13.5 oz | 810069510972 (single) | JAN/21/2026 | Undeclared milk allergen |
10810069510979 (case) | JAN/20/2026, FEB/25/2026 |
What caused the issue?
Butter, or more specifically, the milk in butter was not declared in the ingredient list or allergen warning. A Class II recall means the product may cause temporary or reversible health issues, but serious effects are unlikely.
This poses real risks for those with milk allergies:
- Health risks: From hives and nausea to anaphylaxis in severe cases
- Most at risk: Individuals with milk allergies or lactose intolerance
- Symptoms: Rash, swelling, digestive issues, breathing trouble
As of now, no illnesses have been reported.
Questions you might have
1. What exactly is wrong with the sauce?
The issue is an undeclared allergen—milk—which isn’t listed on the label. It’s a big deal for people with milk allergies who rely on ingredient labels to stay safe.
2. I already used it. What should I do?
If you don’t have a milk allergy, you’re in the clear. If you do have a milk allergy and already consumed the product, contact your doctor right away—even if you’re not showing symptoms yet.
3. How can I tell if my bottle is part of the recall?
Check the UPC and lot number on the label.
4. Where can I find the lot number and best by date?
Usually printed on the neck or back label of the bottle—look for a small code near the “Best By” date.
5. Can I return the product if I have it?
Yes! Return it to the place of purchase for a refund or dispose of it properly. Do not consume it if you have a milk allergy.
6. Was anyone hurt because of this?
As of now, there have been no confirmed illnesses or allergic reactions. The recall is precautionary, but still important.
7. Where was this product sold?
It was distributed to retail centers in Kansas, Florida, New Hampshire, California, Iowa, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, Connecticut, Wisconsin, New York, Washington, and Pennsylvania.
8. How did the company discover the labeling issue?
Old World Spices & Seasoning identified the undeclared milk during an internal label review. Once the oversight was confirmed, they promptly initiated the recall to protect consumers with allergies.
9. Is it safe to keep buying Lillie’s Q products?
Yes—this recall doesn’t affect all Lillie’s Q products, just the Buffalo Wing Sauce with the specified lot codes. The brand and manufacturer are cooperating with the FDA and retailers to resolve the issue.
10. Where can I get more information or updates?
Visit the FDA recall page here or contact Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc. directly. Also, check back on our blog—we’re here to keep you informed!
Here’s what you should you do
If you’ve got one of these bottles in your pantry, here’s your action plan:
- Check the label: Look for lot numbers 002125, 002025, or 005725 and the “Best By” dates listed above
- Spotted one?: Don’t consume it, toss it or return it
- Concerns: Contact the company or consult your doctor if symptoms occur
- Contact Info: Reach Old World Spices at 1-800-xxx-xxxx (you know the drill: M-F, 9-5 CST)
Behind the brand
Old World Spices & Seasoning, Inc., based in Overland Park, Kansas, is known for producing high-quality sauces and seasonings under multiple brands. Lillie’s Q, with its Southern roots and bold BBQ lineup, has a strong presence in specialty food stores. This isn’t the first time brands have recalled undeclared allergens. This past week, Dr. Praeger’s recalled its California veggie fries due to undeclared soy allergen, as well as Trophy Nut Co. that recalled its Heinen’s Honey roasted peanuts due to undeclared cashews.Clearly, allergens continue to be a top concern across the board.
“Allergen labeling might seem like a small detail, but it carries big responsibility. Every missed declaration is a potential health risk. That’s why traceability and rigorous checks should be embedded in every stage of production—from formulation to final packaging.” Eran Mizrahi, CEO of Source86
Ensuring safe eats
Food recalls like this one underscore a bigger picture: accurate labeling its essential. When manufacturers miss key allergens, they don’t just risk fines—they risk lives.
So, what’s the takeaway for manufacturers and wholesale buyers?
- Double-check those labels—especially composite ingredients like butter
- Ensure thorough FSQA checks before shipping
- Know your supply chain—especially if you’re a bulk buyer or private label manufacturer
Looking for reliable, allergen-conscious ingredients? Let’s chat. Our team at Source86 is here to help you source the good stuff—without the risk. Explore our products or contact us for a safer sourcing journey!
