Little Temptations Recalls Chocolatey Eyeballs Over Undeclared Milk Allergen

NORTH ARLINGTON, N.J. (August 31, 2026): The U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced that Crystal Temptations is recalling Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs because the products contain undeclared milk.

The affected products reached Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Sierra Trading Post stores across 13 states. So far, no illnesses have been reported in connection with the recall, according to the FDA-posted announcement.

Little Temptations recall: quick summary

Specifically, the recall covers Chocolatey Eyeballs in five package sizes, ranging from 7 oz. to 16 oz. Consumers can identify the affected products by five style numbers associated with different packaging formats.

According to the FDA notice, a TJX analyst discovered that the products contained whey without declaring milk on the packaging. Subsequently, the company linked the issue to a temporary breakdown in its production and packaging processes.

What happened?

According to the FDA notice, Crystal Temptations recalled its Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs after a TJX analyst identified an allergen labeling problem. Specifically, the analyst discovered that the products contained whey, a milk ingredient, while the packaging did not disclose milk.

Following the discovery, an investigation linked the issue to a temporary breakdown in the company’s production and packaging processes. The FDA announcement does not provide further details about the breakdown.

Additionally, the affected products had been distributed through Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Sierra Trading Post stores across 13 states. As of the recall announcement, no illnesses had been reported.

Affected products

Style number	Product	Size	Packaging	Issue
54040-CHEY	Chocolatey Eyeballs	10 oz.	Plastic bag with designed header card	Undeclared milk
54077-CHEY	Chocolatey Eyeballs	7 oz.	Acrylic box with designed paper wrap	Undeclared milk
58008-CHEY	Chocolatey Eyeballs	10.5 oz.	Round plastic jar	Undeclared milk
58089-CHEY	Chocolatey Eyeballs	16 oz.	Designer plastic pouch bag	Undeclared milk
54083-CHEY	Chocolatey Eyeballs	11 oz.	Plastic bag tied with a tag	Undeclared milk

What caused the issue?

According to the FDA-posted announcement, the Chocolatey Eyeballs contained whey, a milk ingredient, that was not disclosed on the packaging. The company later linked the labeling issue to a temporary breakdown in its production and packaging processes, though it provided no further details.

Importantly, undeclared milk poses a risk to people with a milk allergy or severe sensitivity. Consuming the affected products could cause a serious or potentially life-threatening allergic reaction.

So far, no illnesses have been reported in connection with the recall.

FSQA Insight

“Allergen information needs to remain consistent across the product specification, approved artwork, and the label that ultimately reaches production,” said Sweet Carpio, Document Management Specialist at Source86.

“Controlled document versions and clear approval records can help prevent an outdated or incomplete label from being used when packaging formats or product information change.”

Here’s what you should do

Consumers who purchased the recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs should:

• Check the package for Chocolatey Eyeballs in 7 oz., 10 oz., 10.5 oz., 11 oz., or 16 oz. sizes.
• Look for style numbers 54040-CHEY, 54077-CHEY, 58008-CHEY, 58089-CHEY, or 54083-CHEY.
• Destroy the affected product as instructed in the recall announcement.
• Do not consume the product if you have a milk allergy or severe sensitivity.
• Remember that retailers will not provide refunds at the point of sale.
• Contact Crystal Temptations directly with proof of purchase to request a refund.
• Call 1-201-246-7990, Monday through Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time, with recall questions.
• Seek medical attention if you experience symptoms of a serious allergic reaction after consuming the product.

Behind the brand

Crystal Temptations is a North Arlington, New Jersey-based candy company that says it has operated since 1995. According to the company’s website, it specializes in creative candy presentations and gift-oriented confectionery products.

The company also offers confectionery products for holidays and other occasions, including packaged chocolates, candy arrangements, and novelty items.

Other relevant recalls

• Donutful Recalls Chocolate-Dipped Vanilla Cake Donuts Over Undeclared Milk
• Frankie’s Organic Recalls Plant-Based Vegan Cheddar Puffs Over Undeclared Milk
• Prince Bakery Recalls Breads Over Undeclared Milk and Sesame
• Jaime’s Spanish Village Recalls Jalapeño Ranch Over Undeclared Egg Allergen

Regulatory context

Beyond the immediate recall, the Crystal Temptations case highlights the importance of maintaining accurate allergen information throughout production and packaging.

For manufacturers, allergen controls extend beyond identifying which ingredients enter a formulation. Teams also need processes that ensure ingredient and allergen information remains accurate across every package format.

This is particularly important when products are sold in multiple sizes or packaging configurations. Documented label reviews and packaging verification can help identify discrepancies before products reach consumers.

More broadly, manufacturers, Co-Manufacturers, Co-Packers, and Private Label brands can strengthen allergen controls by aligning formulation records, packaging specifications, and label approvals throughout production.

Ensuring safe eats

Ultimately, the Crystal Temptations recall reinforces the importance of allergen verification throughout production and packaging. Accurate labeling helps consumers with food allergies identify products they can safely consume.

For now, consumers should avoid the recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs and follow the company’s instructions for disposal and refunds.

Meanwhile, Source86 supports food companies with bulk ingredient sourcing, supplier management, FSQA oversight, Private Label production, and supply chain management. Contact us to learn more about building safer and more transparent food operations.

FAQs